I saw TMNT recently with a few of my buddies/former CompUSA coworkers, and was pleasantly surprised. If you go into this movie knowing it was made for younger people, you can wax nostalgia (if you grew up with the Turtles like I did) and not be disappointed. In today’s
Hollywood, action movies seem to have the following requirements, in this order: really cool fight scenes, in your face special effects, 1-dimentional characters, funny 1-liners, and a plot to tie all of the other things together (most often really hastily). Let’s address the pros and cons of each one.
*Warning-plot spoilers ahead*
1. Really cool fight scenes.
Pro: Probably half of this movie was fight scenes. Leonardo fighting the guerillas in South America, the Turtles fighting monsters, the Foot Clan fighting monsters, the Generals fighting monsters, the Turtles fighting the Foot Clan, the Turtles fighting the Generals, Raphael fighting criminals, Raphael fighting one of the monsters, Raphael fighting Leonardo. I’m sure I’ve left out some of the groups fighting, but you get the idea. There were so many different groups fighting, each where there different style, that you couldn’t have asked for more.
Con: One of the scenes has the Foot Clan and the Turtles trying to fight a monster and the Turtles, at best, fought to a draw with it. The 4 Generals come in and annihilate the monster with one fell swoop. Later in the movie the four Turtles are fighting the 4 Generals and you don’t need me to tell you who won.
2. In your face special effects. I won’t go into the pros and cons of this one, because the movie was animated and it would be comparing apples to oranges if I compared this to a live action movie with CGI. I will say, though, that the overall film style of the movie seemed to be planned out, and didn’t seem to be thrown together, which was good.
3. 1-Dimensional characters.
Pro: If you remember the song from the original cartoon, all 4 Turtles are the basic definition of 1-dimensional and this movie didn’t deviate from that. Leonardo was the leader, Donatello was the braniac, Raphael was the hothead, and Michelangelo was the partier. Also, Splinter was the wise master, Casey Jones was the not-too-bright musclehead, the Generals were pure warriors, the Foot Clan were the mindless drone fighters. The only multidimensional characters in the movie were April O’Neil and Winters.
Con: The movie focused on Leonardo and Raphael a lot and basically relegated Donatello and Michelangelo to the back burner. When I was growing up, Donatello was my favorite Turtle because I was a nerd and he was the nerd of the group. I was very perturbed that they didn’t focus more on him.
4. 1-liners
Pro: There were at least 5 or 6 1-liners that made the theatre crack up, which was expected if you watched the cartoon.
Con: Splinter didn’t get one 1-liner. How can you expect us to believe that he lives with 4 wise-cracking teenagers and doesn’t ever joke around with them? How does he get them to listen to him if he can’t relate to them?
5. Plot.
Pro: If you go into this movie knowing it was made for younger people (hence the PG rating), you can wax nostalgia (if you grew up with the Turtles like I did) and not be disappointed. The plot was as deep as Citizen Kane or Psycho, or even Die Hard, but it wasn’t as simple as Barney or Teletubbies either. I feel the depth of the plot was just enough to balance out the two intended audiences, my generation who grew up on it and the new generation they are trying to get into it.
Con: There were a few holes in the plot that could have been better planned out, most notably the Turtles/Generals fight mentioned earlier.
All of the cons mentioned above didn’t bother me too much, but there was one thing that stood out that drove me crazy and was the first thing mentioned by all of us when the movie was over: Splinter’s voice I thought he sounded like Harry Caray, the former broadcaster, most notably for the Chicago Cubs, and that is not a compliment. I kept expecting Splinter to say “And thhere’s a shhallow pop flly to shecontbaash, Shandberg shettles undernease it, and the shide is retired.” I realize I am making fun of two dead guys (Caray and Mako, the guy who did the voice of Splinter) but seriously, it sounded like Slinter was being voiced by a drunken white guy doing a poor impression of an old Japanese Sensei.
Overall I thought the movie was pretty good and it easily met my expectation for what it was going to be. I give it solid B grade, but I’m not sure if I will buy it on DVD.