Super Bowl XLIII Prediction
There are many different ways to go about making your prediction for who will win a certain game, but there is only one absolute truth…no one knows for sure who will win until the game is actually played (putting aside players cheating/shaving points or having a gross mismatch, like an NFL team vs a PeeWee team). The reason everyone knows the definition of the word upset is because they happen with such great frequency. Given that upsets happen all the time, there are still things you can look at to help predict who will probably win the game. Here are some of these factors that might influence the Super Bowl and which team has the advantage in each.
1. Which team has the better defense? Statistically, the Pittsburgh Steelers have a much better defense when compared to the Arizona Cardinals, but you can’t just compare the defenses to each other because they don’t play each other. You need to compare the defense vs the offense it is facing as well. During the regular season Arizona’s offense averaged 365.8 yards per game (4th in the NFL) and scored 427 points (3rd) while Pittsburgh’s offense averaged 311.9 yards per game (22nd) and scored 347 points (20th). Quite the difference. Defensively, Arizona gave up 331.5 yards per game (19th) and 426 total points (28th) while Pittsburgh only gave up 237.2 yards per game (1st) and 223 total points (1st). In the postseason, Arizona has improved its defense, while Pittsburgh has remained as stout as ever. Basically what it comes down to is this: One of the best offenses (Arizona) vs the best defense (Pittsburgh) and a not so good offense vs a fairly poor defense that is getting better.
Advantage: Pittsburgh, by a fair amount, but not as much as it initially seems.
2. Which team has the better running game? In the regular season neither team was in the Top 20 in the NFL in rushing with Arizona finishing dead last, so a slight advantage to Pittsburgh there. In the postseason Pittsburgh’s rushing yards per game has increased by less than 3, whereas Arizona has an increase of almost 40 yards per game. Pittsburgh’s star running back, Willie Parker, was hurt for part of the regular season, so you would expect to see an increase in their rushing total with him back, but you don’t. Arizona’s running backs seem to have fresh legs, since they were used so infrequently during the regular season.
Advantage: Arizona.
3. Have the players on either team been here before? A decent amount of the Steelers’ players were on the Super Bowl winning team a few years ago, so they know what it is like to be under this microscope. However, that could actually come back to bite them. That Super Bowl was played in Detroit, so they didn’t really have much of an option but to concentrate on the game. This Super Bowl is being played in Florida, so there is a lot more temptation to go to a few parties, hang out at the beach, and generally not prepare as much for this SB as they did for that SB. For Arizona, Kurt Warner has played in two previous Super Bowls, and Edgerrin James played with a lot of good Indianapolis teams, so he is used to pressure filled games, too. I’m not going to research, but odds are there are some other players for the Cardinals that have played in a Super Bowl, too. Even if Warner is the only player for the Cardinals to play in a Super Bowl, he knows what it takes to win a Super Bowl, so he will get his team prepared. Also, the Arizona Cardinals are from, duh, Arizona, so the warm weather won’t mean as much to them.
Advantage: Pittsburgh.
4. Can either team play the “No one believes in us” card? The Super Bowl will be the fouth postseason game the Arizona Cardinals will play this season and it will be the fourth postseason game in which they are underdogs. Two of those four games were at home and a third (the SB) is at a neutral site. A lot of people, including yours truly, complained that Arizona probably shouldn’t have even made it into the playoffs because they just barely won a horrible division. Yeah, they can play this card.
Advantage: Arizona, big time.
5. Intangibles. Arizona has cheerleaders, Pittsburgh doesn’t. For those of you who read Tuesday Morning Quarterback on ESPN.com know that this could prove to be a big advantage for Arizona. Also from TMQ, “The three teams to have allowed the most points per game and reach the Super Bowl are the 2008 Cardinals, 2007 Giants and 2006 Colts.” See a trend? Arizona coach Ken Whisenhunt and assistant head coach/offense line coach Russ Grimm both coached a lot of the players on the Steelers, so they have an advantage of knowing their opponent better than Pittsburgh does Arizona. Pittsburgh has been featured on the cover of Sports Illustrated the last two weeks. Anyone familiar with the SI cover jinx? Arizona will have the best player on the field in Larry Fitzgerald.
Advantage: Arizona
Score Prediction: Arizona 23-Pittsburgh 19

